Best Chicken Treats That Are Actually Healthy: What We Feed Our Backyard Flock

This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

If you’ve ever walked out to your coop with a bowl of kitchen scraps and watched your chickens come running like you’re holding gold, you know the joy of treat time. But here’s the thing — after our first year of keeping backyard chickens, I started wondering if everything we were tossing over the fence was actually good for them. Turns out, not all chicken treats are created equal, and some of the stuff you’ll see recommended online can actually cause more harm than good.

So today I’m sharing what we’ve learned about the best chicken treats that are actually healthy — the stuff our flock goes crazy for that also supports their egg production, feather health, and overall wellbeing. Because just like feeding our kids, I want to be intentional about what goes into our animals too.

Why Healthy Treats Matter for Backyard Chickens

Chickens aren’t just little garbage disposals (even though they act like it sometimes). What they eat directly affects their egg quality, immune system, and longevity. Too many treats — especially the wrong kind — can lead to obesity, reduced laying, and nutritional deficiencies.

The general rule of thumb is that treats should make up no more than 10% of your flock’s diet. The rest should come from a quality layer feed. But within that 10%, you can really boost their nutrition with the right choices.

When I first started researching chicken nutrition, I picked up Storey’s Guide to Raising Chickens and it became my chicken-keeping bible. It goes deep on nutrition, health, and husbandry in a way that’s thorough but still accessible. If you’re serious about keeping a healthy flock, it’s worth having on your shelf.

Our Favorite Healthy Chicken Treats

Leafy Greens and Garden Scraps

This is the easiest category because it’s basically free if you have a garden. Our chickens go absolutely bonkers for:

• Kale and collard greens
• Lettuce (especially the outer leaves)
• Swiss chard
• Cucumber ends and peels
• Zucchini (we have an abundance every Florida summer)
• Watermelon rinds — a lifesaver in our brutal July heat

Here in Northwest Florida, we can grow greens nearly year-round, which means our flock gets fresh produce even in January. If you’re not gardening yet, the wilted stuff from your fridge works great too. Those slightly sad spinach leaves? Chicken gold.

Mealworms and Black Soldier Fly Larvae

Protein is huge for chickens, especially during molting season when they’re regrowing feathers. Dried mealworms are like chicken crack — seriously, they lose their minds — but I try to use them sparingly because they’re high in fat.

Black soldier fly larvae (often sold as “BSFL” or under brand names) are actually more nutritious with better calcium-to-phosphorus ratios. We keep a bag in the feed room and use them as a training treat when we need the girls to go back in the run.

Herbs from the Garden

This is where things get fun, especially if you’re already into a nature-based lifestyle. Chickens benefit from many of the same herbs we use:

• Oregano — natural immune support
• Basil — antibacterial properties
• Mint — pest deterrent and cooling in summer
• Lavender — calming and helps repel insects in the coop
• Parsley — packed with vitamins

I’ll often toss a handful of fresh herbs into the run or hang bundles in the coop. It’s like aromatherapy for chickens, and the kids love helping harvest.

Fermented or Sprouted Grains

If you want to level up your chicken-keeping game, try fermenting their regular feed or sprouting grains like wheat berries or barley. Fermentation increases nutrient availability and adds probiotics. Sprouting creates fresh greens from a bag of seeds.

We do this especially in winter when fresh greens are harder to come by. It takes some planning, but it’s a great hands-on project for homeschool science too — hello, germination lesson!

Pumpkin and Squash Seeds

Every fall, we save the guts from our pumpkins and butternut squash. The seeds are believed to have natural deworming properties (though not a replacement for actual treatment if you have a parasite problem). The flesh is nutritious too, and chickens will pick a pumpkin clean if you let them.

What to Avoid Giving Your Chickens

Not everything is safe. We steer clear of:

• Avocado pits and skins — contain persin, which is toxic to chickens
• Raw or dried beans — contain harmful lectins
• Anything moldy — can cause respiratory issues
• Salty or heavily processed foods — their little kidneys can’t handle it
• Chocolate or caffeine — toxic
• Onions and garlic in large amounts — can affect egg taste and cause anemia

When in doubt, I look it up before tossing it over the fence.

Making Treat Time Part of Your Homeschool Day

One of the unexpected blessings of backyard chickens is how naturally they fit into a Charlotte Mason approach. My kids have learned so much about animal behavior, nutrition, and responsibility just by caring for our flock daily.

We’ve started keeping notes in our nature journals about what treats the chickens prefer, how their egg production changes with the seasons, and which hen is the bravest about trying new foods (it’s always our Buff Orpington, in case you were wondering). It’s real, living science happening right in our backyard.

For families just starting out with chickens, I always recommend A Kid’s Guide to Keeping Chickens. It’s written at an elementary level and covers feeding, care, and even simple health checks in a way kids can actually own. My oldest used it to create her own chicken care checklist.

Keeping the Coop Clean While You’re At It

Healthy treats are only part of the equation. A clean coop matters too. We sprinkle food-grade diatomaceous earth in the nesting boxes and dust bathing areas to help with mites and lice naturally. And we upgraded to a nipple-style chicken waterer last year to keep their water cleaner — game changer, especially in Florida where everything gets algae in about five minutes.

A Few Final Thoughts

Feeding our chickens well is just one small piece of the intentional life we’re building here. It’s connected to growing a garden, cooking from scratch, and teaching our kids where food actually comes from. There’s something deeply satisfying about collecting eggs from hens you’ve raised on good food and sunshine.

If you’re thinking about getting chickens — or if you already have them and want to do better — just start where you are. Swap out the stale bread for some leafy greens. Toss in some herbs. Watch your flock thrive.

And if you need me, I’ll be out back with a bowl of watermelon rinds and a very enthusiastic group of hens at my feet.

Happy homesteading, friend.